LED Headlamps Continue Their Evolution
December 9, 2015 by John Day
By Tony Armstrong
Director of Product Marketing, Power Products
Linear Technology Corporation
If you’re like me, you can still remember the traditional tungsten filament light bulb. I say this because the 40W and 60W incandescent light bulbs typically used in the majority of American homes were banned from being manufactured in the USA, or imported, at the end of 2013 (however they can still be purchased). It should also be noted that the 75W and 100W bulbs were phased out in 2012. The cause of their demise was driven by the need for better electrical-to-light output efficacy demanded by the EPA. The primary reason was to help lower electricity consumption (and therefore generation) due to the fact that residential household lighting accounted for roughly 14% of electrical power consumption (Source: US Energy Information Administration). And so, the solid state LED equivalent, requiring only about one-eighth of the power to generate the equivalent amount of lumens output has made its way into our modern world.
This sequence of evolutionary lighting changes, from the incandescent light bulb to solid state electronic equivalents, is analogous to the current migration occurring in the automotive industry with vehicle lighting.
While red LEDs have been used in taillights for over a decade, it is the changes in the car’s interior and forward illumination lighting systems which have only recently made significant strides in LED adoption rates. For example, LEDs are found in over 70% of interior indicator lights and over 45% for instrument display backlights. Contrast this with the daytime running lights (DRLs) at over 55% and headlamps at approximately 5% today. I, for one, find it ironic that although the headlamp (low beam, high beam, fog lamps) represents the single largest opportunity, they are also the least penetrated! One of the major reasons for this apparent paradox is the cost for the automakers to implement them at a price the consumer is willing to pay.
Before I get into the background behind the low headlamp adoption rate, it is useful to understand why many drivers, and even the OEMs, prefer LED lighting solutions. These include, but are not limited to, the following:
• Performance and design flexibility. LEDs enable design flexibility due to their form factor and provide a broad range of dimming capabilities. Remember that the human eye is very sensitive to minor deviations in light output.
• Energy saving and lower CO2 emissions. Not only do LEDs have better power efficiency thereby reducing the energy required to power them, but they also have significantly longer life cycles.
• Cost. This may seem counter intuitive, but in non-headlamp applications, continued cost decreases, durability and superior quality have made LEDs the new standard in end-customer value.
• Regulation. Government regulations that specify requirements for DRLs and headlamps, as well as other lighting applications, have increased LED lighting demand.
I do not think it will come as a surprise to anyone that Audi is generally considered to be the leader when it comes to the use of LEDs in virtually any exterior automotive lighting application. Their famous “eyebrow” DRLs are very noticeable to anyone who sees them in their rearview mirror. Furthermore, they were the first to use LED headlamps in the 2004 Audi R8.
So why is it that LED headlamps have not taken off as well as the LEDs used in the other forms of automotive LED lighting? Well, the answer is, of course, cost. The alternatives to using LEDs in the headlamp are: incandescent bulbs, halogen bulbs or high-intensity discharge (HID) Xenon bulbs. Comparable LEDs can cost up to 100% more than halogen headlamps (originally introduce in 1962 in Europe, but not adopted in the USA until 1978) and as much as 1.5 times more than HID Xenon bulbs (achieving comparable performance to HID Xenon headlamps requires a much more expensive LED solution than for lower-performance halogen alternatives). By the way, the first HID Xenon headlamp appeared on the 1991 BMW 7 series.
Generally speaking, LED headlights are stacked in between the halogen and HID lamps regarding their luminescence, but they provide much more focused rays and can also be controlled to create different shapes. Also, thanks to their small size, LEDs allow for great manipulation, with automotive manufacturers being able to create all kinds of shapes and assemblies that would perfectly match their models. Although LEDs do not emit heat as they light up, they do create a certain amount of heat at the bottom of the emitter when the electricity passes through, thus creating a potential risk for adjacent assemblies and connectivity cables. For this reason, LED headlamps need cooling systems, such as heat sinks or fans to keep them from melting. Furthermore, these cooling systems are located in the engine bay, a not-so-cool area for some other system to maintain a decent temperature. This is another reason why LED headlights are also harder to design and implement in the vehicle, and thus more expensive than HIDs.
Figure A. An example showing how a matrix LED headlamp disperses light
But that’s not all. I recently read an article in the US trade press that stated Audi now has an optional laser high beam in its high-performance R8. This system is excellent at not shining light on vehicles traveling ahead of it that the high-beam can remain on and adjust itself, even with as many as eight cars in front. Compared to LED high-beams, Audi’s laser spotlight can throw its beam twice as far down the road (over 500 feet), allowing the driver greater distance visibility.
New ICs Facilitate LED Headlamp Adoption
Unlike incandescent light bulbs where all that is needed to create light output is to pass an electric current through its filament, LEDs require specialized integrated circuits to drive them.
Figure 1. I2C 8-switch matrix dimmer LED driver IC
One key performance feature that an LED driver IC must have today is the ability to adequately dim LEDs. Since LEDs are driven with a constant current, where the DC current level is proportional to LED brightness, to vary the LED brightness, there are two methods of dimming the light by controlling the LED current. The first method is analog dimming in which the LED DC current level is reduced proportionally by lowering the constant LED current level. Reducing the LED current can result in a change in LED color or inaccurate control of the LED current. The second method is digital or pulse-width-modulation (PWM) dimming. PWM dimming switches the LED on and off at a frequency at, or above 100Hz, which is not perceivable to the human eye. The PWM dimming duty cycle is proportional to LED brightness, while the on-time LED current remains at the same level as set by an LED driver IC, maintaining constant LED color during high dimming ratios. This method of PWM dimming can be used with ratios of 3,000:1 in some applications.
Specifically, in the case of driving high brightness LEDs, Linear Technology’s LED driver ICs are capable of delivering sufficient current and voltage for many different types of LED configurations in a conversion topology that satisfies both the input voltage range and required output voltage and current requirements. Thus, Linear’s high brightness LED driver ICs typically have the following qualities:
• Wide input voltage range
• Wide output voltage range
• High efficiency conversion
• Tightly regulated LED current matching
• Low noise, constant frequency operation
• Independent current and dimming control
• Wide dimming range ratios
• Small compact footprint with minimal external components
Linear Technology has a wide variety of products to address the specific design needs of driving the LEDs commonly found in automotive headlamps. A recent example is the new LT3965, an 80V input and output voltage capable, constant-current, constant-voltage converter. This topology enables it to drive high current LEDs. See Figure 2. It features an internal low side N-channel power MOSFET rated from 84V at 3.3A, which is driven from an internal regulated 7.15V supply. The fixed frequency, current-mode architecture results in stable operation over a wide range of supply and output voltages. A ground referenced voltage FB pin serves as the input for several LED protection features and also makes it possible for the converter to generate as a constant-voltage source. A frequency adjust pin lets the user to program the frequency from 100kHz to 1MHz to optimize efficiency, performance or external component size.
The LT3956 senses the output current at the high side of the LED string (commonly called high side current sense). This is the most flexible scheme for driving LEDs, enabling boost, buck mode, or buck boost mode configurations.
Figure 2. The LT3956 circuit schematic for driving a series string of LEDs
I believe it is clear, despite the low level penetration rate of LED headlamps today, that advances in performance features are too alluring for automotive manufactures to forego LED headlamps for much longer. These reasons include improved safety for the driver, body styling flexibility, energy savings and pure good looks. And we all know that a cars looks make us want to buy them. Watch for matrix lighting when you are driving around, because you are going to see a major increase in it and the use of LED headlamps when you look in your rearview mirror.